Before the 2023 NFL Draft, Kincaid was projected to crack the top-15 picks. However, in late November, fate dealt him a blow when a back injury reared its ugly head. This setback prevented him from participating in the physical evaluations at the combine in February. Nevertheless, Kincaid defied the odds and showed his mettle by attending team interviews, where he flaunted his football IQ and unwavering ardor for the game.
As the draft day got closer, Kincaid's stock plummeted due to concerns about his injury and the emergence of other late first-round wide receivers. Yet, the Buffalo Bills discerned his potential and craftily maneuvered to secure him with the 25th pick, trading up two spots.