Buffalo Bills Offseason Shakeup: James Cook, Amari Cooper and More

The Buffalo Bills are facing one of the most critical offseasons in recent memory. After another deep playoff run that fell short of a Super Bowl, roster decisions will shape the team’s future. From James Cook’s contract demands to potential wide receiver re-signs, Buffalo’s front office has major moves to consider.

James Cook Wants a Payday – Will the Bills Give It to Him?

James Cook had a breakout season, proving himself as one of the Bills’ most consistent offensive weapons. But now, he wants to get paid. Cook recently took to social media, posting a cryptic message about a $15 million per year contract. Then, in a move that had fans buzzing, he removed all Bills-related content from his profile.

It’s a classic negotiation tactic, but will it work?

Right now, Cook is extension-eligible but still under contract for another season. That means Buffalo doesn’t have to rush a deal, and the team could hold its ground. However, Cook’s impact on the offense makes this a tough decision.

On one hand, he’s an explosive playmaker who keeps defenses honest and gives Josh Allen a reliable option. On the other hand, paying top-tier money for a running back who doesn’t play 50 percent of snaps is risky.

If Cook sticks to his demand of $15 million per year, the Bills may have to decide:

• Pay him and lock in a talented back for years

• Trade him and invest in a cheaper option

• Let him play out his contract and reevaluate later

Which direction makes the most sense?

Could the Bills Replace Cook With Ray Davis?

There’s another layer to this debate—rookie Ray Davis showed flashes of being a long-term solution. He runs with power, finds gaps, and even had a 150-yard game when given a larger role.

If the Bills think Davis can take over, they might be more willing to let Cook go. It wouldn’t be the first time Buffalo has moved on from a talented running back to free up cap space.

The Tight End Room Is Set – But Can Dawson Knox Justify His Contract?

Buffalo doesn’t need to worry about the tight end position, but there’s still a debate about Dawson Knox’s contract. His deal made sense when he signed it, but his production hasn’t matched the price tag.

Dalton Kincaid is clearly the future at the position, but Knox still plays an important role in blocking and as a secondary target. The Bills probably won’t move on from him now, but his contract will be a conversation next year if his production doesn’t improve.

Backup QB Plans – Should the Bills Draft a Developmental Quarterback?

Josh Allen isn’t going anywhere, but Buffalo still needs a reliable backup. Mike White is under contract, but should the Bills draft a young QB to develop behind Allen?

Some teams have found success investing in late-round quarterbacks, grooming them as solid backups or even flipping them for picks down the road. It’s a low-cost move that could bring value later.

Big Decisions Ahead

The Bills’ offseason will be full of tough decisions. James Cook’s contract situation, the possibility of adding a star receiver, and key depth moves at multiple positions will all shape Buffalo’s roster for 2025.

So what’s the right move? Should Buffalo pay Cook or trade him? Should they go all in on a receiver like Amari Cooper? And how will free agency and the draft impact these decisions?

One thing is certain—this offseason will be one to watch.

Go Bills!

---